A Comparison of Nurtec ODT to Maxalt MLT-ODT in Adult ED Patients With Migraine Headache

This is a prospective, randomized, double-blind superiority trial evaluating and comparing analgesic efficacy and safety of Rimegepant ODT 75 mg to Rizatriptan ODT 10 mg in adult patients presenting to the ED of Maimonides Medical Center with acute migraine headache.

The investigators will conduct the study in the emergency department of Maimonides Medical Center, an urban emergency department that receives over 120,000 adult visits annually. The emergency department is staffed on weekdays by salaried, trained, bilingual (English and Spanish) research associates who execute research studies under the supervision of the principal investigators. Adult patients between ages of 18 and 65 presenting to the ED with an acute exacerbation of a migraine without aura as defined by the International Classification of Headache Disorders, 3rd edition criteria for migraine without aura or for probable migraine without aura, with an initial pain score of 5 or more on a standard 11- point (0 to 10) numeric rating scale, and requiring oral analgesia as determined by the treating attending physician will be eligible for participation. Subjects' screening and enrollment will be performed by study investigators and research assistants. All patients will be enrolled at various times of the day when study investigators will be available for patient enrollment and an ED pharmacist will be available for medication preparation.

Each patient will be approached by research associates for acquisition of written informed consent and Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act authorization after being evaluated by the treating emergency physician and determined to meet study eligibility criteria. When English will not be the participant's primary language, a language- appropriate consent form will be used and non-investigator, hospital-employed, trained interpreters or licensed telephone interpreter will assist in acquisition of informed consent. Baseline pain score will be determined with an 11-point numeric rating scale (0 to 10), described to the patient as "no pain" being 0 and "the worst pain imaginable" being 10.

Research associates will ascertain the subject's headache level every 30 minutes after medication administration for up to 120 minutes. If enrolled subjects required more pain medication at or after one hour had elapsed, they will be given additional medication at the discretion of the treating physician.

The research team will be contacting all of research subjects by telephone 24 hours after ED discharge to ascertain headache status, satisfaction with treatment, and presence of adverse events.

All data will be recorded on data collection sheets, including patients' sex, demographics, medical history, and vital signs, and entered into SPSS (version 24.0; IBM Corp) by the research manager. Confirmation of written consent acquisition for all participants, and statistical analyses will be conducted by the institutional biostatistician who will work independently of any data collection.

As a primary measure of headache intensity, the investigators utilized a standard, validated, and reproducible 11-point numerical rating scale (NRS). This scale uses patients' responses in assigning their pain a number between 0 and 10, with 0 representing no pain and ten representing the worst pain imaginable. Secondary measurement scales included a standard four-point pain intensity categorical scale, in which patients describe their pain as "severe", "moderate", "mild", or "none" and a four-point functional disability scale, in which patients describe their headache-related disability as severe ("cannot get up from bed or stretcher"), moderate ("great deal of difficulty doing what I usually do and can only do very minor activities" ), mild ("little bit of difficulty doing what I usually do"), or none. These scales will be used in accordance with the recommendation by the International Headache Society for use in migraine research.

One hour after medication administration, the investigators will ask all of enrolled patients if they needed more medication for pain. Lastly, we will assess enrolled patients' satisfaction (efficacy and tolerability of the study drug) with treatment by asking each of them, 24 hours after enrollment, whether they would want to receive the same medication the next time they visited the ED with an acute migraine.

The primary outcome for this study will be a comparison of change in numerical rating scale score between baseline and one hour between two investigational arms.

Secondary outcomes will include:

1. A comparative change in pain score between two groups at 120 minutes

2. A frequency of rescue analgesia at 60 and 120 minutes

3. Sustained headache freedom, defined as achieving a level of "none" on the severe, moderate, mild, and none scale within 2 hours of investigational medication administration and maintaining this level continuously for 24 hours without use of rescue medication.

4. Sustained headache relief, defined as change within 2 hours of the patient's description of headache from severe or moderate to either mild or none without use of rescue medication, and maintaining this level of relief continuously for 24 hours.

5. Headache relief in the ED, defined as change within 2 hours of the patient's description of headache from severe or moderate to either mild or none without the use of rescue medication

6. Headache freedom in the ED, defined as achieving a headache level of "none" within 2 hours without use of rescue medication

7. Achieving a normal functional status by two hours

8. The patient's overall assessment of efficacy and tolerability, expressed as a dichotomous response to the question "Do you want to receive the same medication the next time you visit the ER with a migraine?"