Background In 2020 an estimated 10 million people fell ill with tuberculosis (TB) and 1.5
million people died making TB the second leading infectious killer after COVID-19. Multi-drug
resistant tuberculosis is a public health crisis and increasing health security threat.
Despite this, the only currently available vaccine for prevention of tuberculosis is the
100-year-old Bacille Calmette-Guerin (BCG), which prevents disseminated forms of tuberculosis
but has limited efficacy against pulmonary tuberculosis.
Phase 3 vaccine trials for tuberculosis are large, costly and conducted over prolonged
periods. Controlled human infection models involve inoculating healthy participants with an
infectious agent and can be used to accelerate vaccine development as well as improve
understanding of disease pathogenesis and the host immune response and the development of new
therapeutic combinations. There are current concerns in using wild type Mycobacterium
tuberculosis as a human challenge agent given that infection cannot be reliably eradicated.
The McShane group in Oxford have established a human challenge model using intradermal BCG
and have published several peer reviewed articles. The Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine
propose to replicate and further refine this model and I will be undertaking this project as
part of an MD. The investigators aim to perform serial skin sampling paired with respiratory
mucosal and systemic sampling to investigate and compare the immune response between these
compartments. Ultimately this model may be used to select the most promising candidates for
clinical trials.
Study hypothesis
BCG SSI strain will be recovered by tissue biopsy 14 days after intradermal injection by
both classical microbiological and molecular diagnostic techniques.
Quantified BCG recovery (molecular techniques) by minimally invasive skin biopsy will be
at least 90% as good as gold standard punch biopsy and will offer a more acceptable
method for participants in the future.
Overall study design This is a single-centre study divided into two parts. The first part of
the study (phase A) will recruit 10 participants. The participants in phase A will receive
intradermal injection of BCG SSI vaccine into the upper arm on day 0 at three times the usual
dose (BCG SSI 6-24 x 105 colony forming units). On day 14 after BCG injection. the following
skin samples will be taken from the BCG injection site with the use of local anaesthetic:
skin swab, microbiopsy, skin scrape and punch biopsy. The overall aim of this part of the
study will be to ensure BCG can be isolated from participants BCG intradermal injection site
14 days after the injection. The investigators aim to test whether BCG can be isolated in
comparable amounts by punch biopsy and minimally invasive techniques (microbiopsy, skin
scrape and skin swab). They will proceed to phase B of the study if they are able to isolate
BCG by culture or PCR using one of the minimally invasive techniques and no serious adverse
events have occurred.
In the second phase of the study (phase B) 20 participants will be recruited. These
participants will receive the BCG vaccine as described for phase A. The minimally invasive
technique with the best BCG recovery will be used to perform longitudinal skin sampling to
monitor BCG growth and the local skin immune response. Parallel samples will be taken from
the respiratory mucosa and blood to compare the immune response in these compartments.
Study procedures
Consent:
In both phases of the study the consent and screening process will be the same. Potential
participants will be invited to discuss the study at a 60 minute appointment, where they will
watch a presentation on the study and complete a consent quiz to demonstrate understanding of
the study and capacity to consent.
Screening:
To assess eligibility for the study, a focused medical history will be taken. If deemed
necessary by the research team, GP questionnaires will be sent to GPs of participants if
their vaccination history or medical history is unclear. A clinical examination will be
performed including cardiorespiratory examination. Vital signs will be taken, as well as a
nose and throat swab for COVID-19 lateral flow test (if required by UKHSA) and storage, urine
pregnancy test (females only). The following blood tests will be taken: HIV test, hepatitis
serology, full blood count and clotting, stored serum, blood PBMCs.
BCG intradermal injection (day 0):
For both parts of the study, at the BCG injection visit, participants will receive a single
injection of the BCG vaccine at three times the usual dose intradermally into the upper arm.
A CE marked intradermal delivery device (NanoPass MicronJet, NanoPass Technologies Ltd) will
be used, which is licensed for the intradermal delivery of liquid drugs including vaccines
for standardised intradermal delivery. After this visit participants will complete an
electronic diary for 14 days to report any adverse events. Throughout the study, participants
will have access to a 24/7 on-call telephone service.
Follow-up phase A:
In phase A, participants will attend follow-up appointments on days 2, 7, 14, 21 and 28 after
BCG. A skin swab will be taken from the BCG injection site and a photograph of the site at
each follow-up visit. The following blood tests will be taken: serum and PBMC for immunology
ate each follow up visit and blood RNA on day 2.
In addition participants will attend on day 14 for skin biopsies. Local anaesthetic will be
injected around the BCG vaccination site and the following skin samples will be taken in this
order:
Microbiopsy - This instrument uses a hollow needle to take a skin sample of 0.21mm
diameter, 0.4mm depth.
Skin scrape - This will take a sample from the skin surface using a Rhino-probe.
Punch biopsy - This will take a skin sample from the middle of the BCG site using a 4mm
punch biopsy instrument.
Follow-up Phase B:
In phase B participants will attend for follow-up visits on days 2, 7, 14, 21 and 28 after
the BCG injection as with phase A.
In addition, in phase B the following respiratory mucosal samples will be taken from the nose
on days 0, 2, 7, 14, 21 and 28 in phase B:
Nasal wash will be performed in a subset of participants only- the nose is irrigated
with normal saline and the liquid that is produced is collected and analysed
Nasosorption - participants will have small pieces of filter paper inserted into
nostrils for maximum of 2 minutes
Nasal scrape - small superficial scrapes are taken from inside the nose to collect nasal
cells
The following skin samples will be taken from the BCG vaccination site: Microbiopsy OR
skin scrape (depending on results of phase A) AND Skin swab on days 0, 2, 7, 14, 21 and
28
Laboratory mycobacteriological analysis
Skin biopsy specimens will be cryopreserved and subsequently processed in batch
Skin samples will be thawed and homogenised then cultured on Middlebrook 7H11 agar for 4
weeks before counting.
The remaining biopsy specimen homogenate will be stored at -80° for subsequent DNA
extraction
The remaining homegenate will be thawed and DNA will be extracted and quantitative PCR
will be performed
Laboratory immunological analysis Antibody responses: Samples of serum and nasosorption will
be retained for antibody measurement using standard ELISA assays.
Cellular responses: Ex Vivo Interferon γ (IFN-γ) Enzyme-Linked Immunospot (ELISpot) assays
will be performed on freshly isolated PBMCs from all participants. Responses to purified
protein derivative (PPD) from M. tuberculosis will also be assessed. Unstimulated PBMCs will
be used as a measure of background IFN-γ production. Results will be reported as spot-forming
cells per million PBMCs, calculated by subtracting the mean count of the unstimulated PBMCs
from the mean count of triplicate antigen wells and correcting for number of PBMCs in the
well.
RNA analysis: Samples will be retained for transcriptomic signature feasibility testing.
These methods will be essential as the CHIM develops for vaccine testing.
Reporting procedures for serious adverse events (SAEs) and suspected unexpected serious
adverse reactions (SUSARs):
Adverse events will be actively and passively solicited. A symptom diary will be completed
for the first 14 days to identify any adverse events and adverse events will be solicited at
follow-up visits and recorded in the participant eCRF. Any serious adverse event considered
by the CI to be related to the challenge agent and unexpected will be reported to the REC. As
the challenge agents are vaccines with Marketing Authorisation, the mechanism for reporting
any SAEs to the MHRA is via yellow card.
Data and Safety Monitoring Committee (DSMC)
The specific role of the committee will be:
To independently review SAEs and AESIs regardless of relatedness to any of the study
procedures throughout the study.
To formally review the safety profile and quantified BCG recovery rate
To perform unscheduled reviews on request of the study team at a demand and frequency
determined by the severity of reported adverse events.
The DSMC will be supplied with a safety report at the end of the study, in the event of an
SAE, or if requested at any time by the CI or DSMC members.
The Chair of the DSMC will also be contacted for advice where the CI feels independent advice
or review is required.