A Comparison Between a PC and a CC Approach for the Placement of Infraclavicular Perineural Catheters in Hand Surgery

Last updated: March 17, 2026
Sponsor: Centre hospitalier de l'Université de Montréal (CHUM)
Overall Status: Completed

Phase

N/A

Condition

Chronic Pain

Pain

Post-surgical Pain

Treatment

Placement of an infraclavicular perineural catheter using a costoclavicular approach

Placement of an infraclavicular perineural catheter by paracoracoid approach

Clinical Study ID

NCT04960046
21.114
  • Ages > 18
  • All Genders

Study Summary

In outpatient hand surgery, 40% of patients report moderate to severe pain within 24 hours of the operation. Effective pain management is therefore essential to ensure a comfortable and safe return home for the patient.

Loco-regional anesthesia is the optimal method of analgesia for complex hand surgery. It involves the injection of a local anesthetic (LA) near the nerves responsible for the sensitivity of the arm. Following a single injection of long-acting local anesthetic, the maximum duration of analgesia is limited to approximately 13 hours, with great variability between individuals. In order to provide pain relief over a longer period of time, placing catheters near nerves has become a routine practice at the CHUM.

Infraclavicular nerve block is one of the most widely used loco-regional anesthesia techniques for hand surgery. This block can be achieved either by paracoracoid (PC) or costoclavicular (CC) approach. Both approaches are currently used at the CHUM.

The PC approach involves inserting a needle under the lower rim of the clavicle below the coracoid process. This approach makes it possible to reach the 3 different nerve bundles, located around the axillary artery, which are involved in the sensitivity of the hand.

The CC approach, more recently described, proposes an insertion of the needle under the lower edge of the clavicle but in a lateral way to the axillary artery which makes it possible to reach the nerves at a place where the 3 main nerve bundles are still joined together. The clustering of nerve structures at the injection site may facilitate the spread of local anesthetics.

Recent studies have demonstrated that the CC approach requires a smaller volume compared to the PC approach to achieve perineural blockade. The effective dose 90 (ED90) for the CC approach was 19 mL while it is 31 mL for the PC approach. This is explained by the greater proximity between the three nerve bundles targeted in the CC approach and a lower prevalence of anatomical variations at this level.

However, studies on the subject are rare and do not allow conclusions to be drawn on the superiority of either approach.

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion

Inclusion Criteria:

  • Patients over 18 years old

  • American Society of Anesthesiologists' classification 1 to 3

  • Patients undergoing elective ambulatory hand surgery requiring the use of continuousinfraclavicular nerve block

Exclusion

Exclusion Criteria:

  • Contraindication to a peripheral nerve block

  • Refusal of the patient or inability to consent

  • Inability to communicate with the healthcare team or the research team

  • Lack of access to the Teams telehealth platform

  • Inability to understand the items of the different questionnaires

  • Inability to understand ambulatory catheter follow-up instructions

  • Pregnancy

  • Obesity Body Mass Index > 40

  • Pre-existing neurological deficit in the operated upper limb

  • Anatomical malformation not allowing one of the study blocks to be performed

  • Condition preventing measurement of the primary outcome

Study Design

Total Participants: 140
Treatment Group(s): 2
Primary Treatment: Placement of an infraclavicular perineural catheter using a costoclavicular approach
Phase:
Study Start date:
October 25, 2021
Estimated Completion Date:
April 04, 2025

Study Description

The aim of this study is to determine whether the costoclavicular approach (CC) provides a better sensory block 48 hours after catheter installation than the infraclavicular block performed by the paracoracoid approach (PC).

In the context of continuous perineural blocks performed on an outpatient basis, LAs are delivered after insertion of a catheter by a low flow elastomeric pump (maximum 5 mL/h). Considering that the nerve structures are closer to each other with the CC approach, the investigators hypothesize that with the same mode of administration, the efficacy of the continuous block at 48 h obtained by the CC approach will be greater than the block produced by the PC approach.

Methods

Patients scheduled to undergo an upper limb surgery requiring a continuous infraclavicular nerve block will be contacted by a member of the research team before surgery to receive information regarding the study and obtain informed consent.

After obtaining consent, participants will be randomly assigned to two groups:

Group A: Placement of an infraclavicular perineural catheter by paracoracoid approach; Group B: Placement of an infraclavicular perineural catheter using a costoclavicular approach.

Only the anesthesiologist performing the technique and his assistant will know the group to which the patient has been assigned. The blocks will be carried out in a standardized manner and in accordance with the establishment's procedures. After bringing the patient to the induction room and installing the recommended monitoring equipment, the anesthesiologist will administer an intravenous premedication. The patient will be installed in a supine position. After disinfecting the skin, the anesthesiologist will inject a small amount of local anesthetic to numb the skin in the area where the block will be performed and then locate the nerve bundles under ultrasound guidance using the approach to which the patient has been assigned (Group A or B). When the area has been located, the injection of a local anesthetic (bupivacaine) will be performed and the catheter installed and fixed. Multimodal analgesia will be used for postoperative pain relief including acetaminophen, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and hydromorphone as needed.

Thirty minutes after the catheter insertion, a sensory-motor assessment of the blocked territory will be performed. During surgery, the patient may be sedated or receive general anesthesia at the discretion of the anesthesiologist. The surgery will be performed according to the usual procedure.

In day-care surgery, a disposable elastomeric pump will be installed to ensure the perineural infusion of LA. The patient will receive the usual information about postoperative analgesia and the use of the pump. Follow-up details will be reviewed with the patient prior to discharge from hospital.

A follow-up teleconsultation will be made the day after surgery and two days after surgery. As part of these calls, the following items will be assessed: sensory level and motor function of the forearm, level of pain and opioid use, presence of side effects, quality of sleep and satisfaction towards the analgesic technique used.

All patients will benefit from a daily follow-up call by nurses from the Acute Pain Service (APS) for up to 72 hours. In the absence of adverse effects, catheters will be removed by patients 72 hours after surgery.

Connect with a study center

  • Centre hospitalier de l'Université de Montréal (CHUM)

    Montreal, Quebec H2X 3E4
    Canada

    Site Not Available

  • Centre hospitalier de l'Université de Montréal (CHUM)

    Montréal, Quebec H2X 3E4
    Canada

    Site Not Available

  • Centre hospitalier de l'Université de Montréal (CHUM)

    Montreal 6077243, Quebec 6115047 H2X 3E4
    Canada

    Site Not Available

Map preview placeholder

Not the study for you?

Let us help you find the best match. Sign up as a volunteer and receive email notifications when clinical trials are posted in the medical category of interest to you.