Pragmatic Randomized Trial of Proton vs. Photon Therapy for Patients With Non-Metastatic Breast Cancer: A Radiotherapy Comparative Effectiveness (RADCOMP) Consortium Trial

Last updated: November 4, 2025
Sponsor: Abramson Cancer Center at Penn Medicine
Overall Status: Active - Not Recruiting

Phase

N/A

Condition

Breast Cancer

Cancer

Treatment

Proton

Photon

Clinical Study ID

NCT02603341
UPCC 19115
  • Ages > 21
  • All Genders

Study Summary

A pragmatic randomized clinical trial of patients with locally advanced breast cancer randomized to either proton or photon therapy and followed longitudinally for cardiovascular morbidity and mortality, health-related quality of life, and cancer control outcomes. Quality of life is the outcome measure for the estimated primary completion date of December, 2024, www.radcomp.org.

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion

Inclusion Criteria:

  • Females or males diagnosed with pathologically (histologically) proven invasive mammary carcinoma (ductal, lobular or other) of the breast who have undergone either mastectomy or lumpectomy with any type of axillary surgery or axillary sampling.

  • For patients who have undergone lumpectomy, any type of mastectomy and any type of reconstruction (including no reconstruction) are allowed.

  • For patients who have undergone lumpectomy, there are no breast size limitations.

  • Patients with non-metastatic breast cancer are eligible. This includes American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) 7th edition left- or right-sided breast cancer clinical or pathologic stage I, II, III or loco-regionally recurrent at time of diagnosis. For patients that receive neoadjuvant chemotherapy, AJCC 7th edition left- or right-sided breast cancer pathologic stage yp 0, I, II, III are eligible.

  • Bilateral breast cancer is permitted. Patients with bilateral breast cancer will be stratified as left-sided.

  • Must be proceeding with breast/chest wall and nodal radiation therapy including internal mammary node treatment.

  • Must have a pertinent history/physical examination within 90 days prior to registration.

  • Age ≥ 21 years

  • ECOG Performance Status 0 - 2 (asymptomatic to symptomatic but capable of self-care) within 90 days prior to randomization.

  • Confirmation that the patient's health insurance will pay for the treatment in this study (patients may still be responsible for some costs, such as co-pays and deductibles). If the patient's insurance will not cover a specific treatment in this study and the patient still wants to participate, confirmation that the patient would be responsible for paying for any treatment received.

  • Patients who are HIV positive are eligible, provided they are under treatment with highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) and have a CD4 count ≥ 200 cells/microliter within 180 days prior to registration as documented in the medical record. HIV testing is not required for eligibility for this protocol.

  • The patient must provide study-specific informed consent prior to study entry.

Exclusion Criteria

  • Definitive clinical or radiologic evidence of metastatic disease, as documented by the treating institution.

  • Prior radiotherapy to the ipsilateral chest wall or ipsilateral breast or thorax. Individuals with prior radiotherapy in the contralateral breast or chest wall are eligible.

  • Any radiation therapy for the currently diagnosed breast cancer prior to randomization.

  • Dermatomyositis with a CPK level above normal or with an active skin rash or scleroderma.

  • Other non-malignant systemic disease that would preclude the patient from receiving study treatment or would prevent required follow-up.

Study Design

Total Participants: 1238
Treatment Group(s): 2
Primary Treatment: Proton
Phase:
Study Start date:
April 06, 2016
Estimated Completion Date:
November 30, 2036

Study Description

Because no one knows which radiation treatment is best, if you decide to take part in this study, you will be randomly assigned to 1 of 2 treatment groups, and then you will begin radiation treatment according to usual medical practice. Randomly assigning you to a group helps makes sure that each group has a similar mix of patients and makes the study better - and is only done when doctors are not sure whether one treatment is better than the other. You have an equal chance of getting into either treatment group, like a coin flip. Both you and your doctor will be told which treatment you will get.

No matter which group patients are in, doctors will work very carefully to reduce the radiation to healthy tissues. Both groups will followed for at least 10 years after completing radiation therapy. The results of this study will help decide which radiation is best for future patients with your type of breast cancer.

Connect with a study center

  • University of Alabama

    Birmingham, Alabama 35233
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Alabama

    Birmingham 4049979, Alabama 4829764 35233
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Mayo Clinic-Arizona

    Phoenix, Arizona 85054
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Mayo Clinic-Arizona

    Phoenix 5308655, Arizona 5551752 85054
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • UC San Diego

    San Diego, California 92121
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • UC San Diego

    San Diego 5391811, California 5332921 92121
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Georgetown University Medical Center

    Washington, District of Columbia 20007
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Georgetown University Medical Center

    Washington D.C. 4140963, District of Columbia 4138106 20007
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Miami Sylvester Cancer Center at Coral Gables

    Coral Gables, Florida 33146
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Miami Sylvester Cancer Center - Deerfield

    Deerfield Beach, Florida 33442
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Florida Health

    Gainesville, Florida 32610
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Mayo Clinic Florida

    Jacksonville, Florida 32224
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Florida Health Proton Therapy Institute

    Jacksonville, Florida 32206
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Miami Cancer Insititute

    Miami, Florida 33176
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Miami Sylvester Cancer Center

    Miami, Florida 33136
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Orlando Health

    Orlando, Florida 32806
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Miami Sylvester Cancer Center at Coral Gables

    Coral Gables 4151871, Florida 4155751 33146
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Miami Sylvester Cancer Center - Deerfield

    Deerfield Beach 4153071, Florida 4155751 33442
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Florida Health

    Gainesville 4156404, Florida 4155751 32610
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Florida Health Proton Therapy Institute

    Jacksonville 4160021, Florida 4155751 32206
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Miami Cancer Insititute

    Miami 4164138, Florida 4155751 33176
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Miami Sylvester Cancer Center

    Miami 4164138, Florida 4155751 33136
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Orlando Health

    Orlando 4167147, Florida 4155751 32806
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Emory University

    Atlanta, Georgia 30322
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Emory University

    Atlanta 4180439, Georgia 4197000 30322
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Northwestern Medicine Proton Center

    Chicago, Illinois 60190
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Northwestern Medicine Proton Center

    Chicago 4887398, Illinois 4896861 60190
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Willis Knighton

    Shreveport, Louisiana 71103
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Willis Knighton

    Shreveport 4341513, Louisiana 4331987 71103
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Johns Hopkins

    Baltimore, Maryland 21287
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Maryland

    Baltimore, Maryland 21201
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Johns Hopkins

    Baltimore 4347778, Maryland 4361885 21287
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Maryland

    Baltimore 4347778, Maryland 4361885 21201
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Massachusetts General Hospital

    Boston, Massachusetts 02114
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Mass General/North Shore Cancer Center

    Danvers, Massachusetts 01923
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Massachusetts General Hospital

    Boston 4930956, Massachusetts 6254926 02114
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Mass General/North Shore Cancer Center

    Danvers 4934500, Massachusetts 6254926 01923
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • McLaren Proton Therapy

    Flint, Michigan 48532
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • William Beaumont

    Royal Oak, Michigan 48073
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • McLaren Proton Therapy

    Flint 4992982, Michigan 5001836 48532
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • William Beaumont

    Royal Oak 5007804, Michigan 5001836 48073
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Mayo Clinic-Rochester

    Rochester, Minnesota 55905
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Mayo Clinic-Rochester

    Rochester 5043473, Minnesota 5037779 55905
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Washington University, St. Louis

    Saint Louis, Missouri 63110
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Washington University, St. Louis

    St. Louis, Missouri 63110
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Washington University, St. Louis

    St Louis 4407066, Missouri 4398678 63110
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • RWJ University Hospital Hamilton

    Hamilton, New Jersey 08690
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • RWJ University Hospital Hamilton

    Hamilton Township, New Jersey 08690
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Cancer Institute of NJ

    New Brunswick, New Jersey 08903
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • ProCure Proton Therapy Center

    Somerset, New Jersey 07728
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • RWJ University Hospital Hamilton

    Hamilton 5098765, New Jersey 5101760 08690
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Cancer Institute of NJ

    New Brunswick 5101717, New Jersey 5101760 08903
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • ProCure Proton Therapy Center

    Somerset 5104755, New Jersey 5101760 07728
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center

    New York, New York 10065
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • New York Proton Center

    New York, New York 10035
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center

    New York 5128581, New York 5128638 10065
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • New York Proton Center

    New York 5128581, New York 5128638 10035
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Cincinnati

    Cincinnati, Ohio 45267
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University Hospitals, Case Medical Center

    Cleveland, Ohio 44106
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University Pointe, University of Cincinnati

    West Chester, Ohio 45069
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Cincinnati

    Cincinnati 4508722, Ohio 5165418 45267
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University Hospitals, Case Medical Center

    Cleveland 5150529, Ohio 5165418 44106
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University Pointe, University of Cincinnati

    West Chester 4520522, Ohio 5165418 45069
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Oklahoma City Procure

    Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73142
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Oklahoma University - Stephenson Cancer Center

    Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73104
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Oklahoma University - Stephenson Cancer Center

    Oklahoma City 4544349, Oklahoma 4544379 73104
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Pinnacle Health Cancer Institute

    Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17109
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Lancaster General Hospital

    Lancaster, Pennsylvania 17601
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Abramson Cancer Center at Penn Medicine

    Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Abramson Cancer Center of the University of Pennsylvania

    Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Chester County Hospital

    West Chester, Pennsylvania 19380
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Pinnacle Health Cancer Institute

    Harrisburg 5192726, Pennsylvania 6254927 17109
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Abramson Cancer Center at Penn Medicine

    Philadelphia 4560349, Pennsylvania 6254927 19104
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Chester County Hospital

    West Chester 4562144, Pennsylvania 6254927 19380
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Provision Center for Proton Therapy

    Knoxville, Tennessee 37909
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Thompson Proton Center

    Knoxville, Tennessee 37909
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Thompson Proton Center

    Knoxville 4634946, Tennessee 4662168 37909
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • UT Southwestern

    Dallas, Texas 75390
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • MD Anderson Cancer Center

    Houston, Texas 77030
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Texas Center for Proton Therapy

    Irving, Texas 75063
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • MD Anderson Cancer Center

    Houston 4699066, Texas 4736286 77030
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Texas Center for Proton Therapy

    Irving 4700168, Texas 4736286 75063
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Inova Schar Cancer Institute

    Fairfax, Virginia 22031
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Inova Schar Cancer Institute

    Fairfax 4758023, Virginia 6254928 22031
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Seattle Cancer Care Alliance

    Seattle, Washington 98133
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Washington

    Seattle, Washington 98195
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Seattle Cancer Care Alliance

    Seattle 5809844, Washington 5815135 98133
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Washington

    Seattle 5809844, Washington 5815135 98195
    United States

    Site Not Available

Map preview placeholder

Not the study for you?

Let us help you find the best match. Sign up as a volunteer and receive email notifications when clinical trials are posted in the medical category of interest to you.