Comparative Effectiveness of Prophylactic ICD Versus Non-ICD Therapy

Last updated: January 7, 2026
Sponsor: University of Rochester
Overall Status: Active - Recruiting

Phase

N/A

Condition

Chest Pain

Hyponatremia

Congestive Heart Failure

Treatment

ICD implantation

Clinical Study ID

NCT06543446
ADVARRA
  • Ages > 18
  • All Genders

Study Summary

The investigators aim to compare the risk of mortality of Non-implantable carioverter defibrillator (ICD) vs. ICD management in patients with heart failure with reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF).

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion

Inclusion Criteria:

  • Age ≥ 18 years (no upper limit)

  • Class I or IIa indication for a primary prevention ICD15: Ischemic or non-ischemiccardiomyopathy and NYHA Class ≥ II if most recent LVEF is ≤ 35% OR ischemiccardiomyopathy with NYHA Class I if most recent LVEF is ≤ 30%

  • Most recent LVEF (%) obtained per cardiac imaging obtained at any time prior toenrollment after being stable on optimal GDMT** for at least one month

  • Stable optimal GDMT at least one calendar month prior to last cardiac imaging test,prespecified as one of the following for at least 1 calendar month prior to studyrandomization:

receiving all 4 therapy classes (beta-blockers, ARNI/ARB/ACE, MRA and SGLT2i) OR GDMT Score ≥ 6 (per Figure 7)

• MADIT-ICD Benefit Score < 50 (per Figure 4)

Exclusion

Exclusion Criteria:

  • Existing ICD/CRT-D

  • • Planned CRT-P or CRT-D implant for any indications including Class I or IIaindication for CRT: Presence of left bundle branch block (LBBB) with QRS ≥ 120 msecOR QRS duration ≥ 150 msec regardless of QRS morphology OR decision for CRT implantby EP provider for other indications

  • Acute MI within the past 3 calendar months

  • Chronic renal failure requiring hemodialysis

  • Coronary revascularization within the past 3 calendar months

  • History of sustained VT or VF

  • Known genetic cause of cardiomyopathy

  • Life expectancy < 1 year

  • Unable or unwilling to follow study protocol

  • Inability to consent

Study Design

Total Participants: 3290
Treatment Group(s): 1
Primary Treatment: ICD implantation
Phase:
Study Start date:
March 04, 2025
Estimated Completion Date:
February 28, 2031

Study Description

The proposed CONTEMP-ICD trial is a prospective, multicenter, open-label, randomized controlled trial; enrolling 3290 participants with HFrEF, on stable and optimal guideline-directed medical therapy (GDMT), who are eligible for a primary prevention ICD, but have a low predicted arrhythmic risk. Enrolled participants will be randomized in a 1:1 ratio to non-ICD vs. ICD treatment arms. The investigators hypothesize that, in participants with HFrEF who have a low predicted arrhythmic risk, non-ICD vs. ICD is non-inferior with respect to the primary endpoint of all-cause mortality and superior survival free of major cardiovascular (CV) events.

This study will recruit adults 18 years of age and older with heart failure. Participants will be asked to complete questionnaires. Information from medical records will be gathered including medical history, physical exam, medications, blood work results, and imaging. Visits will be at initial, three, six months, and every six months beyond six months. For those who get an ICD device an interrogation will be collected at the visits.

Connect with a study center

  • University of Calgary

    Calgary, Alberta T2N4Z6
    Canada

    Site Not Available

  • University of Alberta

    Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2B7
    Canada

    Site Not Available

  • University of Calgary

    Calgary 5913490, Alberta 5883102 T2N4Z6
    Canada

    Active - Recruiting

  • University of Alberta

    Edmonton 5946768, Alberta 5883102 T6G 2B7
    Canada

    Active - Recruiting

  • MaineHealth

    Portland, Maine 04102
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • MaineHealth

    Portland 4975802, Maine 4971068 04102
    United States

    Active - Recruiting

  • Johns Hopkins University

    Baltimore 4347778, Maryland 4361885 21287
    United States

    Active - Recruiting

  • Tufts Medical Center

    Boston 4930956, Massachusetts 6254926 02111
    United States

    Active - Recruiting

  • Corewell Health

    Grand Rapids, Michigan 49503
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Corewell Health

    Grand Rapids 4994358, Michigan 5001836 49503
    United States

    Active - Recruiting

  • Minneapolis Heart Institute Foundation

    Minneapolis, Minnesota 55407
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Minneapolis Heart Institute Foundation

    Minneapolis 5037649, Minnesota 5037779 55407
    United States

    Active - Recruiting

  • Rutgers

    New Brunswick, New Jersey 08901
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • The Valley Hospital

    Paramus, New Jersey 07652
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Rutgers

    New Brunswick 5101717, New Jersey 5101760 08901
    United States

    Active - Recruiting

  • The Valley Hospital

    Paramus 5102387, New Jersey 5101760 07652
    United States

    Active - Recruiting

  • Northwell Health

    New York, New York 10075
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Nuvance Health Hudson Valley Cardiovascular Practice, PC

    Poughkeepsie, New York 12601
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Rochester

    Rochester, New York 14642
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Northwell Health

    New York 5128581, New York 5128638 10075
    United States

    Active - Recruiting

  • Nuvance Health Hudson Valley Cardiovascular Practice, PC

    Poughkeepsie 5132143, New York 5128638 12601
    United States

    Active - Recruiting

  • University of Rochester

    Rochester 5134086, New York 5128638 14642
    United States

    Active - Recruiting

  • Intermountain Health Care, Inc.

    Salt Lake City, Utah 84111
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • Intermountain Health Care, Inc.

    Salt Lake City 5780993, Utah 5549030 84111
    United States

    Active - Recruiting

  • University of Virginia Health System

    Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • University of Virginia Health System

    Charlottesville 4752031, Virginia 6254928 22902
    United States

    Active - Recruiting

  • West Virginia University

    Morgantown, West Virginia 26506
    United States

    Site Not Available

  • West Virginia University

    Morgantown 4815352, West Virginia 4826850 26506
    United States

    Active - Recruiting

Map preview placeholder

Not the study for you?

Let us help you find the best match. Sign up as a volunteer and receive email notifications when clinical trials are posted in the medical category of interest to you.