Spinal anesthesia (SA) involves injecting local anesthetic into the intrathecal space.
Since it was first described, understanding of the physiology and pharmacology of drugs
acting within the subarachnoid space has improved. Physiological changes observed
following SA are believed to be attributed to their blockade of peripheral and cardiac
sympathetic fibers. The changes in cardiac output (CO) observed following SA were
originally thought to be explained by the 'pre-load reduction' theory that describes a
decrease in CO resulting from reduced venous return leading to arterial hypotension.
However, this theory was questioned due to failed attempts to avoid SA induced
hypotension by three preventative techniques: preloading with crystalloids or colloids,
lower limb compression, and lateral tilt maneuvers (1). Additional studies and subsequent
data led to further questioning of the pre-load reduction theory and supported a shift to
an 'after-load reduction' theory. This proposes that hypotension following SA is a result
of sympathetic blockade causing arterial dilatation (1,2). With this knowledge, it has
traditionally been taught to avoid SA in severe aortic stenosis (AS) for risk of
decreased coronary perfusion, while SA has been considered safe, or even beneficial in
those with severe mitral regurgitation (MR). However, there is a paucity of real time
evidence to help support these claims. Furthermore, individuals with experience in
performing SA in patients with severe AS and/or MR have questioned the hemodynamic
effects that are traditionally described (3).
With advancements in echocardiographic techniques, point of care ultrasound has emerged
in critical care to become the standard for evaluating hemodynamic changes observed in
hemodynamic instability or cardiovascular collapse (4). This provides an opportunity to
assess CO, and its associated parameters including venous return, preload, afterload, and
contractility, in real time. With this tool, one can compare the hemodynamic changes in
patients with AS or MR before and after high SA given for their cardiac surgery for valve
replacements or repair (AVR or MVR).
Hypothesis and Study Objectives:
This study may provide real time information to support or challenge traditional
understanding of the hemodynamic changes seen following SA in those with severe AS or
severe MR. Since, hemodynamic stability is goal in all patients after any type of
anesthesia, the primary objective is to compare requirement of vasopressors, inotropes,
and inodilators required to maintain desired hemodynamic goals (Mean arterial pressure
65-100 mmHg and HR 50-100/min) and to observe and compare hemodynamics alteration by
using echocardiographic parameters of venous return, cardiac index (CI), preload,
afterload, and cardiac contractility using myocardial performance index (Tei index) (5)
before and after high SA in patients having predominant severe AS or MR. Furthermore,
subgroup analysis will be conducted to compare hemodynamic parameters and medication
requirements to meet target hemodynamic goals among patients with preserved and reduced
left ventricular systolic function (for AS reduced LVEF < 50 %, for MR reduced LVEF <
60%).
Methodology:
This prospective observational study will be conducted at St. Boniface Hospital,
Winnipeg, Canada. All adult patients above 18 years of age, irrespective of their gender,
ASA physical status, and LVEF requiring SA up to T1-2 level block with light general
anesthesia (GA) for their surgical procedures of AVR or MVR will be included. Exclusion
criteria: Mixed valvular lesion (more than mild AR or MS), redo cardiac surgery, not
eligible for fast tracking (i.e., anticipated post-surgical extubation time more than 10
hours (6) of successful uncomplicated surgery, unable of laying supine in 15-degree
Trendelenburg, hypoxic patients (SaO2 less than 94% on room air), difficult airway
requiring awake intubation, patients receiving dialysis, contraindication for
transesophageal echo (TEE) or spinal anesthesia, significant deformity of thoracic and
lumbar spine and poor TTE windows for data acquisition. Patients undergoing associated
CABG for single vessel and without significant regional wall motion abnormalities on echo
(no more than 3 segment involvement), will be included. Patients will be consented for
the study once eligible participants are identified in the cardiac anesthesia PAC clinic.
All TTE parameters will be recorded in the apical 4 and 5 chamber views with a Phillips
echo Apiq 7 machine. The following baseline echo parameters to be recorded will be linear
dimensions of tricuspid valve (TV) and mitral valve (MV) annulus in 4C view left
ventricular outflow tract (LVOT) in Plax view, and LVEF in apical 4C view and LV short
axis view. The linear dimensions of TV and MV annulus and LVOT will also be confirmed on
TEE views and final measurement will be relied on more crisp views. At baseline echo and
repeat assessments, the parameters to be recorded will be velocity time integral (VTI) of
LVOT, MV, TV, tricuspid annular plane systolic excursion (TAPSE) and mitral annular plane
systolic excursion (MAPSE) on M-Mode, and tissue doppler imaging (TDI) of lateral TV and
MV annulus. To calculate LV Tei index Doppler time intervals measured from MV inflow and
LVOT Doppler tracings, as described by Tei and co-workers will be used (5). Tei index
will also be calculated from TDI interrogation using 1.5 mm sample volume from lateral MV
and TV for LV and RV (6,7). For LV Tei index mean of values from TDI and PWD will be used
for analysis. No correction for HR variability will be applied for Tei index below HR
100/min (8). In patients with atrial fibrillation (AF), "pre ejection period
(PEP)-derived MPI (Tei index)" will be calculated since the loss of mechanical atrial
function does not allow measurement of isovolumic contraction time (IVCT) (9). On TEE, a
mid-esophageal (ME) 4 and Deep TG views will be used post intubation for same Doppler and
M mode parameters.
Among cardiac medications only beta blockers will be continued on am of surgery. Once in
the operating room, all patients will have two intravenous lines, ECG, arterial line,
central venous line, pulse oximetry, defibrillator pads, cerebral oximetry and patient
state index (PSi) by Masio monitored. During the study period, Ringer's Lactate will be
infused at a rate of 600ml/hr (100 ml infusion drive line and 500 ml/hr second iv line
which will also be used for drug boluses). Intraoperative hemodynamic parameters will be
automatically recorded by computer interphase system with Philips monitors. A high spinal
will be given using 37.5 mg of 0.75% bupivacaine heavy with 20 mcg fentanyl and 250 mcg
epimorphine in sitting position at the lumbar intervertebral spaces between the L2-3 or
L3-4 vertebrae with 25 G Whitacre or Quincke needle. Patients will lie supine immediately
afterwards, and sensory loss to ice will be performed every 15 seconds. Echo parameters
with TTE will be recorded before spinal, at sensory loss between T10-12 in flat supine.
Subsequently, the patient will be placed in 15-degree Trendelenburg (ensured by
clinometer) and once sensory loss between T4-T8 occurs, a third TTE recording will be
performed while patient being preoxygenated in preparation for GA. Afterwards, patients
will be induced by general anesthesia (GA) in the Trendelenburg position, and a fourth
echo recording will be performed by TEE under GA after putting CVL and first CVP reading
is taken by keeping transducer at heart level in the mid axillary line. Final fifth TEE
echo parameters will be recorded in final surgical position which will be flat supine
with back up to 5 degrees.
A change in SBP or MAP equal to or less than 10% mmHg and HR equal to or less than 10%
beats/min from readings before incision within one minute of skin incision and sternotomy
will be considered "no response" and an effective sensory block unto T1.
General anesthesia will be induced by 0.02-0.03 mg/Kg midazolam (maximum 2 mg), 0.2-0.4
mg/Kg ketamine (maximum 20 mg), 0.3-0.5 mcg/Kg sufentanil, titrated dose of 1-3 mg/Kg
propofol to loss of eye reflex, and rocuronium 1.0-1.2 mg/kg. Intubation will be preceded
with 5 ml of 4% lignocaine spray on the vocal cords and in trachea. Post intubation
anesthesia will be maintained by 50% oxygen with sevoflurane 1-2 % end tidal value
titrated to PSI 30-50 on Massimo monitor, volume control ventilation targeting EtCO2 goal
of 35-40 mmHg. During the study period target hemodynamics will be aimed at MAP between
65-100 mmHg and heart rate between 50-100 beats /min by use of various inotropic,
inodilators and vasoactive cardiac drugs based on anesthesiologists' clinical judgement.
Total dose of boluses and infusions of these drugs used during study period will be
recorded for comparison as cumulated modified vasopressor inotropic inodilator score
index during pre CPB, on CPB and post CPB period till patient leaves the operation room.
This will be calculated as follows:
Total modified VIS score (pre CPB or on CPB or post CPB) = (total dopamine in mcg ) +
(total dobutamine in mcg) + (10 x total milrinone in mcg) + (10,000 x total vasopressin
unit) + (100 x total norepinephrine in mcg) + ( 100 x total epinephrine dose mcg) + (100
x total ephedrine dose in mg) + (10 x total phenylephrine dose in mcg) VIS index = Total
modified VIS score / (weight in Kg x time in minutes)