A Randomized Controlled Trial of No Strings Intrauterine Device (IUD) Removal Techniques

Intrauterine devices (IUDs) are a commonly used, highly effective form of long-acting reversible contraception in the United States. Approximately 4-18% of people with an IUD in place with have missing or non-visible IUD strings, mostly commonly due to IUD string retraction into the cervix. Currently, expert opinion suggests to remove IUDs with no visible strings using by using an alligator forceps that is placed into the uterine cavity with or without ultrasound guidance. Removal of no strings IUDs with manual vacuum aspiration (MVA) has been suggested as a possible alternative to alligator forceps. MVA is a commonly used technique for the management of miscarriage, abortion, and endometrial sampling and has potential benefits as a low cost, portable device that is readily available in family planning clinic and many office-based obstetrics and gynecology practices.

The study will compare MVA to alligator forceps for IUD removal with no visible strings. The investigators will enroll females presenting for no strings IUD removals. Potential participants will be screened for eligibility and will be excluded if they have visible IUD strings, have a positive pregnancy test, have a partially retained IUD (e.g., IUD arm only), or are unwilling to be randomized to either arm. The investigators will perform a screening pelvic exam and transvaginal ultrasound (if not already completed prior to the visit). Participants will then be randomized to one of the two removal techniques: MVA or alligator forceps. The investigators will document successful removal with the first pass of the instrument as well as successful removal with multiple attempts of the same technique. A maximum of 3 MVA removal attempts will be performed after which time, the provider will switch to using an alligator forceps as the current standard of care. Preliminary data will also be collected on patient and provider satisfaction, patient pain scores, procedure time, and complications.

This study will provide important data on MVA as a technique for IUD removals with no visible strings. No studies have compared IUD removal techniques and expanding options for removal techniques has the potential to increase access to care.